a tippling philosopher

Aah, those good, alturistic people.

November 3, 2011
Thank you, this looks delicious.

Thanks to http://www.patheos.com/blogs/unreasonablefaith/ for this.
 

Millican used my (!) argument against the KCA in his debate against Craig.

November 1, 2011
This, from the review by Wintery Knight, shows the refutation to the KCA that I have been banging on about for a year or so is being used against Craig in debate. Finally. Well done Peter Millican.

"1. There is no evidence that whatever begins to exist requires a cause. All the evidence we have of things beginning to exist are when something is created from rearrangements of other things that already existed.

The closest analog we have to something coming into being from nothing is quantum part...


Continue reading...
 

Jedward - evidence for determinism

October 29, 2011


 

 

I am going to use an unlikely tool to show the philosophical veracity of determinism – the belief that we have no free will. The evidence I am going to bring to the stand is / are Jedward. For those who don’t know them, they were X-Factor sensations from Ireland – identical twins who are so similar you just can’t tell them apart. And they do EVERYTHING together.

 

So, let’s look at free will. I do not want to get into the intricacies of free will here (you can read my book...


Continue reading...
 

Ray Bradley vs Craig on hell

October 28, 2011

I have just listened to Ray Bradley debate William Lane Craig. I heard this several years ago but didn't really pay it close attention. This time round I was quite shocked at how many points Craig evaded, or logical demands from Bradley that he met with the terms "God may" and so on.

 

Craig squirmed big time when Bradley pressed him on subsets of compossibles. This is a REALLY important point. I will try to set it out here:

 

Imagine a set of people, call that set A. These are all the people in ...


Continue reading...
 

Good science? Bad science.

October 27, 2011
Christian Big Bang Theory (Found at Joe. My. God.; For a related video, click here http://christiannightmares.tumblr.com/post/241750582/teaching-kids-to-reject-evolution-and-embrace)

Courtesy http://christiannightmares.tumblr.com/page/5 

 

Continue reading...
 

A great article on the circularity of God = Good moral argument

October 24, 2011


Does Morality Depend on God? - P. Wesley Edwards
(updated 20-Aug-2004)

Introduction

I have rarely engaged in a debate with a theist where the issue of morality justification has not come up.  The theist’s complaint typically takes the following form.

If there is no God, then why is it wrong to murder and  steal? Even if you don't want to murder and steal, on what grounds can you criticize someone who does, since morals must be completely relative and arbitrary to an atheist?  Without God there ...


Continue reading...
 

Question

October 24, 2011
What would it take for Christians / The World to stop believing in God?


What is the threshold? What is the evidence needed etc?

Continue reading...
 

Good signage

October 20, 2011
Thanks to Christian Nightmares for this.


Church sign shows how much God loves us (For a related post, click here http://christiannightmares.tumblr.com/post/3727327741/church-sign-god-wants-full-custody-not-just-a)

Continue reading...
 

Stephen Law vs William Lane Craig Debate Review, Part 3

October 20, 2011

So, on to the rebuttals. Craig pointed out in several of his rebuttals that Law has not, and did not seem to want to, critique the cosmological argument. Craig does have some beef here as Law seemed to want to debate Craig’s version of God rather than the more fundamental argument over A God’s existence. Thus in true debate point-scoring, Law would take a hit here. However, as Law plainly stated, and I think this was a wise move, this would have broadened the scope too far and wasn’t im...


Continue reading...
 

Evolution, Natural Selection, True Beliefs, Stephen Law and Plantinga's EANN

October 20, 2011
In a YouTube conversation that I am having, I have been discussing Stephen Law's chat with Alvin Plantinga on Premier Christian Radio's Unbelievable. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyQ5cFIoKts

The poster stated this: "To return to the frog example. Why should natural selection care about the frog's beliefs? If you design a robot to catch flies, it can do so beautifully without having true beliefs - or false beliefs - or any beliefs. So why should natural selection bring beliefs into the equ...
Continue reading...
 

By searching and buying from these Amazon widgets, you are helping me to continue my work blogging and writing, fighting the good fight for reason. 

Free counters!

Tags

Recent Posts